Looking at total profit for the month is close to useless. It is made of setups that earn, setups that lose and mistakes that eat part of what was earned. Analysis separates these parts.
Reviewing a single trade
Ask four questions of every trade and write down the answers.
- 1Was there a setup? The trade matched the description of one of your strategies, or it was improvised.
- 2Was the plan followed? Entry, stop, target and size stayed as intended.
- 3What happened after entry? How far price went against you and how far in your favour.
- 4What would you change? One sentence, no excuses.
The result of the trade is left out of this list on purpose. A planned trade that closed at a loss is still a good trade.
Breakdowns worth looking at
Once you have a few dozen trades, group them. The most useful breakdowns:
| Breakdown | Question it answers |
|---|---|
| Setup or strategy | Which of the things you trade makes money |
| Plan followed or not | What rule breaks cost |
| Instrument | Where you have an edge and where you do not |
| Weekday and time | When you trade profitably |
| Direction | Whether longs and shorts are out of balance |
| Trade duration | Whether you close winners too early |
In each breakdown compare expectancy in R and the number of trades, not profit in money. How to calculate R is explained in the R-multiple guide.
MAE and MFE
MAE shows how far price moved against the position before it was closed. MFE shows how far it moved in your favour.
- If the MAE of winning trades is usually less than half of the stop, a tighter stop is worth testing.
- If the MFE of trades closed at zero or at a loss often exceeded 1R, you are handing back profit that was already there.
- If the MFE of winning trades is well above the actual exit, the target is too close or you close before the plan says so.
From review to decision
Analysis only makes sense if it ends in an action. Once a month, each setup gets one of three decisions:
- Keep. Expectancy is positive on a sample of 30 trades or more.
- Reduce size. The sample is small or the result is unstable.
- Drop. Expectancy is negative on a sufficient sample.
Separately, add up the R on trades that broke the plan. That is the price of mistakes for the month. The most expensive mistake is the first to work on, and the method is described in the trading psychology guide.
Common mistakes in analysis
- Conclusions from a small sample. Five trades prove nothing.
- Judging by the outcome, not the decision. A winning trade that broke the plan reinforces a bad habit.
- Too many breakdowns. The more cuts you make, the easier it is to find a pattern that is pure chance.
- Analysis without writing it down. A conclusion that is not recorded is forgotten within a week.
How an automated journal helps
Importing trades, calculating R and grouping by strategy take more time in a spreadsheet than the review itself. In Tradeart trades arrive from MetaTrader 5, cTrader and DXtrade on their own, statistics by strategy are calculated automatically, and Best Scenario searches your history for the filter combination with the best result. How to keep the records is covered in the trading journal guide.
