The advice "control your emotions" is useless because it does not say what to do on Monday. A working approach is different: find the trades in your journal that were made under emotion, calculate their result and remove the conditions in which they appear.
Why psychology is a matter of record keeping
An emotion does not lose money by itself. The decision made under it does: an entry without a setup, a moved stop, a doubled position. Each such decision can be recorded as an attribute of the trade. When enough of them are collected, you can see what each mistake costs in R.
Mistake 1. Fear of missing out
Price left without you, and you chase it, far from the planned entry. The stop ends up either too wide or too tight.
How to see it: trades without a setup tag or entered after a strong move. Compare their expectancy with that of planned trades.
Mistake 2. Revenge trading
After a loss the next trade is opened quickly, often with larger size and on the same instrument.
How to see it: trades opened within minutes of a losing one. This group is often the most unprofitable of all.
Mistake 3. Fear of taking a loss
The stop is moved further away to "give the trade a chance". A −1R loss turns into −2R.
How to see it: losses larger than −1R. There should be none apart from slippage.
Mistake 4. Taking profit too early
The trade is closed long before the target because the open profit feels fragile.
How to see it: the average win in R is well below the planned one. Check on your history what the original target would have given.
Mistake 5. Raising size after a winning streak
After several good trades the risk goes up. The next loss takes back several wins.
How to see it: risk in money after three or more winning trades in a row is above average.
Mistake 6. Carelessness on a small account
On a demo or a small account the rules are not followed because "it is not serious". The habit moves to the main account.
How to see it: the share of planned trades on the small account is lower than on the main one.
Mistake 7. Trading without a session plan
The session starts without a list of instruments and entry conditions. Trades come from whatever is moving.
How to see it: the number of trades per day varies a lot, and the days with many trades are losing ones.
What to do about it
- 1Tag every trade: planned or not. One field, yes or no.
- 2Add a state field. Calm, tired, irritated, rushed. Four options are enough.
- 3Once a week, add up the price. The sum of R on trades outside the plan. That is what you pay for mistakes.
- 4Remove one condition. If revenge trading costs the most, set a rule: a 30-minute break after a loss.
- 5Check after a month. The share of planned trades should rise and the price of mistakes should fall.
How to set up this kind of record is described in the trading journal guide. The limits that stop a series of mistakes are covered in the risk management guide.
