Tradeart is one of the journals on this page, so read the comparison with that in mind. Prices and plan details come from each vendor's public pages and recent third-party reviews, checked in November 2026. They change often. Confirm on the vendor's site before you pay.
How to choose a trading journal
Four questions sort the options faster than a feature list.
- 1Does it import from your platform automatically? A journal you must feed by hand or by file export is a journal you stop using. Check your exact platform, not only the asset class.
- 2Does the analysis lead to a decision? A hundred reports matter less than one clear answer about which setup makes money.
- 3Can you try it without paying? A free plan or a trial without a card lets you test the import on your own account.
- 4What does a year cost? Monthly prices hide the total. Compare the annual figure.
Comparison at a glance
| Journal | MetaTrader 5 | cTrader | Free option | Paid plans from |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tradeart | Automatic | Automatic | Free plan, plus a Premium trial without a card | See pricing |
| TradeZella | Automatic | Automatic | None | $35 a month |
| Edgewonk | Automatic | By file | None | $197 a year |
| Tradervue | Supported | Check its broker list | Free plan with a monthly trade limit | $29.95 a month |
| TraderSync | Automatic | Automatic | 7-day trial | $29.95 a month |
| TradesViz | Automatic | Check its broker list | Free plan for stocks only | $19.99 a month |
| TraderWaves | Automatic | Check its broker list | Free plan | $29.99 a month |
DXtrade support is rarer. Tradeart imports from it; for the others, check the current broker list before you sign up.
Tradeart
Tradeart is built for traders on MetaTrader 5, cTrader and DXtrade, including prop firm accounts. You connect an account once, and trades import on their own. On MT5 the investor password is enough. The connection is read-only.
Analysis is R-based: every trade is measured against the risk taken, so setups compare fairly whatever the position size. The Best Scenario tool looks for the combination of filters that performed best on your own history, and the RR simulator replays your trades on real candles to show what a different target would have returned. A backtester, an AI mentor, an economic calendar and notes with screenshots sit in the same product.
There is a free plan with manual logging and one strategy. Premium adds automatic sync, unlimited accounts and the analysis tools, with a free trial that needs no card.
Suits: forex and CFD traders on MT5, cTrader or DXtrade, and prop firm traders with several accounts. Less suited to: stock and options traders on US brokers, who are better served by the journals below.
TradeZella
TradeZella is a broad journal with trade replay, backtesting, playbooks and AI features, and it syncs with a long list of brokers. In July 2026 it moved to three plans: Essential at $35 a month, Pro at $59 and Ultra at $99. It has no free plan.
Suits: active traders who want replay and backtesting in one place and trade enough to justify the price. Less suited to: traders who want to test a journal on their own data before paying.
Edgewonk
Edgewonk is one of the older journals and is known for its focus on trading psychology and discipline tracking. It sells a single plan with every feature: $197 a year, or $35 month to month. Many platforms import by file upload, which means exporting a statement and loading it into the journal.
Suits: traders who want structured psychology tracking at a flat yearly price. Less suited to: traders who want every platform to sync without file exports.
Tradervue
Tradervue has been around since 2011 and is strong in stocks, options and futures on US brokers. It has a free plan with a monthly trade limit, Silver at $29.95 a month and Gold at $49.95. It does not offer trade replay or backtesting.
Suits: US equity and futures traders who want mature reporting and trade sharing with a mentor. Less suited to: traders who want replay, backtesting or AI analysis.
TraderSync
TraderSync covers stocks, options, futures, forex and crypto and syncs with a very long broker list, MetaTrader and cTrader included. Plans are Pro at $29.95 a month, Premium at $49.95 and Elite at $79.95, with a 7-day trial and no free plan. It has a market replay simulator and mobile apps.
Suits: multi-asset traders who need wide broker coverage and a mobile app. Less suited to: traders on a budget, since the stronger features sit in the higher tiers.
TradesViz
TradesViz is the most configurable of the group, with a very large number of charts and statistics. Its free plan covers stocks only. Forex and futures need Pro at $19.99 a month or Platinum at $29.99. DXtrade was not on its sync list when last checked.
Suits: data-minded traders who like building their own reports. Less suited to: traders who want a short answer more than a toolkit.
TraderWaves
TraderWaves offers a free plan that is not a trial, with journal, analytics and charts, and a Pro plan at $29.99 a month or $239.88 a year that adds unlimited accounts, backtesting and AI coaching.
Suits: traders who want to start free and stay there for a while. Less suited to: traders who need DXtrade, which is worth checking against its current broker list.
Free alternatives
Two routes cost nothing. Myfxbook tracks MetaTrader accounts for free and shows performance statistics, though it is an account tracker more than a journal: it has no setups, notes or review workflow. A spreadsheet does have those, if you build them. A ready one is on the trading journal template page.
Which one to pick
- You trade forex or CFDs on MT5, cTrader or DXtrade, or hold prop firm accounts: start with Tradeart.
- You trade US stocks and options: look at Tradervue, TraderSync or TradesViz.
- You want replay and backtesting above all and accept the price: TradeZella.
- You want psychology tracking at a flat yearly fee: Edgewonk.
- You want to pay nothing for now: TraderWaves' free plan or a spreadsheet.
Whatever you choose, test the import with your own account in the first week. A journal that does not receive your trades correctly cannot analyse them.
